Ad Fontesto the sources

Christian Violence Against Pagans, Jews, and Other Christians

A history in sections — from the beginnings to the late Inquisitions.

The pattern this essay traces is simple: a church that began as the persecuted became, once it held power, the persecutor — of pagans, of Jews, and of Christians who disagreed with it. The violence was not one excess in one century. It recurs, in different forms, for fifteen hundred years.

1. The beginnings: the persecuted church

For its first three centuries Christianity was the victim, not the agent, of religious violence. The persecutions under Nero (64), Decius (250), and Diocletian (303–311) killed Christians for refusing sacrifice to the emperor. The New Testament itself records the pattern: Stephen stoned (Acts 7), James executed by Herod Agrippa (Acts 12).

The turn comes with power. Constantine’s conversion (312) and the Edict of Milan (313) end the persecutions; within a lifetime the church is writing the laws instead of suffering under them. The first Christian-on-Christian blood is already there in the fourth century: the Donatist schism in North Africa (from 311), where the Circumcellions — bands of Donatist militants — beat and murdered Catholic clergy, and the imperial government answered with soldiers. Both sides killed; the state, once Christian, killed for the church.

2. Alexandria: the bishops and their mobs

Alexandria is where the pattern is clearest, because the same city shows it three times in one century.

Gregory of Cappadocia (339–345). The Arian bishop installed in Alexandria by imperial troops, replacing the exiled Athanasius. Athanasius — a hostile witness, corroborated in outline by Socrates and Sozomen — reports soldiers and Arian partisans beating and imprisoning his Christians and seizing their churches. The violence here is Christian against Christian, over doctrine, enforced by the army.

Theophilus (391). The bishop who destroyed the Serapeum, Alexandria’s great temple of Serapis, after the emperor Theodosius banned pagan sacrifice (391–392). The temple’s destruction was the public announcement that paganism was now a crime. Theophilus’s successor inherited the machine he built.

Cyril (412–444). The Jews of Alexandria expelled in 414, after clashes in the streets. Hypatia, the pagan philosopher, dragged from her chariot and murdered by a Christian mob in 415 — the parabolani, a guild that began tending the sick and the plague dead and became the bishop’s street enforcers, with Nitrian monks alongside them. They had already stoned the prefect Orestes in the street. Theodosius II capped the parabolani at 500 men in 416, the year after Hypatia’s murder — a measure of how out of hand they had become.

The mob cut both ways: George of Cappadocia, the Arian bishop who replaced Athanasius a second time, was himself lynched by an Alexandrian mob in 361, after Julian’s accession. Alexandria’s violence was a weapon any faction could pick up.

3. The imperial church: heresy becomes a capital crime

Theodosius I made Nicene Christianity the state religion (Edict of Thessalonica, 380) and outlawed pagan sacrifice (391–392). Justinian closed the Academy at Athens in 529 — the end of a thousand years of pagan philosophy, by decree.

Priscillian (385). The first heretic executed by a Christian state. A Spanish bishop, condemned for his teachings and executed at Trier on the orders of the emperor Magnus Maximus. Ambrose and Martin of Tours protested — the execution went ahead anyway. The precedent was set: the state would kill for doctrine.

The Christological fights of the fifth century were fought in the streets as well as in councils. Flavian, patriarch of Constantinople, was beaten at the Second Council of Ephesus (449, the “Robber Council”) and died of his injuries days later. Proterius, patriarch of Alexandria, was lynched by a mob in 457. Maximus the Confessor had his tongue cut out and his right hand cut off in 662 for opposing the emperor’s doctrine. Athanasius himself was exiled five times; the exiles were the mild version of the same fight.

4. The medieval church: crusade, inquisition, expulsion

The Crusades against fellow Christians. The Albigensian Crusade (1209–1229) was a war the Church declared against Christians — the Cathars of southern France. At Béziers in 1209 the crusaders massacred the whole town, Catholic and Cathar together. Tens of thousands died across the twenty years of the crusade.

The medieval Inquisition (from 1231). Pope Gregory IX created the papal inquisition to hunt heresy — first the Cathars and Waldensians, then anyone the local bishop named. It ran on denunciation, secret testimony, and torture; the unrepentant were handed to the secular arm to be burned.

The Jews. The First Crusade (1096) began with massacres of Jews in the Rhineland — at Worms, Mainz, and Cologne — by crusaders on their way to Jerusalem. The expulsions followed, one kingdom at a time: England (1290), France (1306, again 1394), Spain (1492, the Alhambra Decree), Portugal (1497). Between the massacres and the expulsions, the Church also attacked the Jews’ books: after the Disputation of Paris (1240), the Talmud was condemned and burned in Paris in 1242 — twenty cartloads, by one account.

5. The Spanish Inquisition and the Roman Inquisition

Spain (1478–1834). Established by Ferdinand and Isabella with the pope’s bull (1478), the Spanish Inquisition was a royal institution with church sanction. Its targets were converts — Jews and Muslims who had become Christians and were suspected of secretly keeping their old faith. The first auto-da-fé was held at Seville in 1481. Over three and a half centuries it tried roughly 150,000 people; the number executed is estimated by modern historians at several thousand (commonly cited figures run between about 3,000 and 5,000). The exact count is disputed; the scale is not. It ended only in 1834.

Rome (from 1542). Pope Paul III created the Roman Inquisition (1542) to meet the Protestant Reformation. Its most famous victim was Giordano Bruno, burned in Rome in 1600 for his teachings. The Roman Inquisition’s other weapon was paper: the Index of Forbidden Books (1559), and the Congregation of the Index (1571) to keep it current. In 1553, Pope Julius III ordered the Talmud burned throughout Italy — the 1242 Paris burning, repeated on a larger scale, now aimed at the books of a whole people.

6. Luther and the Reformation: the violence changes hands

Luther is the proof that the violence was not a Catholic monopoly. He began by attacking the Church’s power and ended by using the same weapons against his own enemies.

The peasants (1525). When the German peasants rose in 1524–1525, Luther wrote Against the Murderous, Thieving Hordes of Peasants, calling on the princes to “smite, slay, and stab” them. About 100,000 peasants were killed in the suppression.

The Jews (1543). In On the Jews and Their Lies, Luther called for synagogues to be burned, Jewish houses destroyed, and Jewish books seized. The tract was later quoted by the Nazis — a fact Luther’s admirers cannot undo.

The Anabaptists. The Anabaptist kingdom at Münster was besieged and destroyed in 1535; its leaders were executed in 1536. Luther’s followers and the Catholics agreed on this one point: the radicals had to die.

The Protestants against each other. John Calvin’s Geneva burned Michael Servetus in 1553 for denying the Trinity — a Protestant city burning a man for heresy, ten years after Luther’s death. The Wars of Religion followed: the St. Bartholomew’s Day massacre in Paris (1572), thousands of Huguenots killed in a single week; and the Thirty Years’ War (1618–1648), which killed millions across Germany — a war of religion that became a war of states, but began as a war of doctrine.

7. Book censorship: violence against the written word

Censorship runs through the whole story as its own kind of violence — the destruction of books is the destruction of a people’s memory.

The censors’ logic was the inquisitors’ logic: a wrong book, left standing, would corrupt souls — so the book had to die, and sometimes its author with it.

The pattern

From Alexandria in 339 to Rome in 1600, the story is one story: power arrived, and the church that had been killed for its faith began to kill for it. Pagans lost their temples, Jews lost their homes and their books, and Christians who read the same Scriptures differently lost their lives. The Reformation did not end the violence; it gave it new hands. The Inquisitions did not end it either; they gave it offices, procedures, and indexes.

The essay does not argue that every Christian was violent, or that the violence was the whole of the story. It argues that the violence was structural — built into the alliance of church and state, and into the belief that error has no rights — and that it lasted, in one form or another, from the fourth century to the nineteenth.

Sources

Primary: Athanasius, History of the Arians and Apology; Socrates, Ecclesiastical History; Sozomen, Ecclesiastical History; Ammianus Marcellinus, Res Gestae; the Theodosian Code (XVI); Luther, Against the Murderous, Thieving Hordes of Peasants (1525) and On the Jews and Their Lies (1543); the papal bulls Exigit sincerae devotionis (1478) and Licet ab initio (1542); the Roman Index (1559).

One point is stated with its uncertainty attached. The Spanish execution totals are a scholarly range, roughly 3,000 to 5,000, not a settled count.