Topic A7 — The second act: 1304–1306 — his student’s ban
The controversy returns
Ramban died in 1270, but the controversy returned a generation later, and its central figure was his own student. Abba Mari of Lunel appealed to the Rashba (Solomon ben Aderet, 1235–1310), who headed the school Ramban had founded in Barcelona.
On July 26, 1305, the Rashba and the Barcelona community banned any member under 25 from studying Greek works on natural science or metaphysics (Jewish philosophical works and medicine excepted), and banned allegorical preaching — for example, Abraham and Sarah as matter and form. Menahem Meiri issued a counter-declaration; Levi ben Avraham of Villefranche was a chief target. The controversy ended with the expulsion of the Jews from France in 1306.
Why it matters
It is the direct institutional legacy of Ramban’s position: his student, not his opponent, carried the restrictive side forward — and the ban he issued was narrower (age-limited, community-limited) than the 1232 bans.
Open questions
How much of the Rashba’s 1305 ban is Ramban’s legacy, and how much is the Rashba’s own? The Rashba was also Ramban’s student in halakha, not only in outlook.
Sources and public-domain verdicts
Abba Mari’s Minchat Kenaot (1838 edition) — public domain.
Rashba responsa, part 1, no. 415 — public domain.
Encyclopaedia Judaica, “Maimonidean Controversy” — under copyright; summarized.
← Topic A6: The outcome: what stuck · Topic A8: The Disputation of Barcelona (1263) →
Back to the Nahmanides hub.