Topic A5 — The substantive disagreements: five fronts
The actual content of the opposition
Dates and bans are only the frame. These five fronts are the philosophical content of “his opposition” — what Ramban actually disputed with Maimonides, in his own texts.
1. Miracles and providence
Maimonides (Guide III:17–19; Shemoneh Perakim, ch. 8; Essay on Resurrection) minimizes miracles: they are unusual occurrences within nature, foretold by the prophet, and providence for individuals is proportionate to intellect.
Ramban (on Exodus 13:16) teaches two kinds of miracle — great public ones and “hidden” ones — and says the hidden miracles “are the foundation of the entire Torah”: a man has no part in the Torah of Moses unless he believes that all his affairs and occurrences are miracles, with no nature or course of the world in them.
A scholarly caution belongs here: Ramban is speaking about Israel and about how the believer must view the world, not necessarily denying natural law as metaphysics.
2. Sacrifices
Maimonides (Guide III:32): sacrifices were a concession — a “second intention” — to wean Israel from idolatry.
Ramban (on Leviticus 1:9): “these words are worthless (divrei havai); they make a big breach, raise big questions, and make the Table of God polluted.” Sacrifices have intrinsic value — psychological value and, “by way of truth” (al derekh ha-emet), a hidden cosmic-theurgical secret.
3. Reasons for the commandments
Maimonides gives rationales for all the commandments (Guide III:26–49). Ramban holds that all commandments have comprehensible reasons — but also hidden ones, and that Maimonides’ historical explanations (sacrifices, the Tabernacle) flatten what is really there. Related to this front is the sin of Eden: for Maimonides there is no Fall and no cosmic tearing; for Ramban there is.
4. Resurrection and the World to Come
Maimonides’ Essay on Resurrection (1191) clarified that he does believe in bodily resurrection. Ramban’s Sha’ar ha-Gemul (the last chapter of Torat ha-Adam) treats reward, punishment and resurrection at length.
A nuance recorded by Oded Yisraeli: Ramban endorsed the fundamentally Maimonidean view that reward and punishment in the afterlife are spiritual, not physical — the disagreement is narrower than the polemics suggest.
Open question, flagged, not answered: the resurrection topic needs a side-by-side of Sha’ar ha-Gemul against Maimonides’ Essay on Resurrection before anything further is written on this front. This page presents only what is stated above.
5. Allegorization of aggadah and anthropomorphism
The banners’ charge was that philosophy allegorizes away the text and loosens observance. Ramban shared the alarm about allegorization — and about mocking aggadot — while rejecting the ban on the books themselves.
Open questions
How far does Ramban’s “hidden miracles” doctrine extend — all Jews at all times, or the righteous? And the resurrection side-by-side named above is wanted before anything further is written on that front.
Sources and public-domain verdicts
The Guide: Friedländer translation (1904) — public domain.
Ramban on Exodus 13:16 and Leviticus 1:9 — Hebrew text public domain; Chavel’s English translation is CC-BY (verified on Sefaria, 2026-11-17 — see the licence note on the hub page). Strand A quotes nothing from Chavel.
Russell Jay Hendel, “Maimonides’ Attitude Towards Sacrifices,” Tradition 13:4–14:1 (1973) — under copyright; summarized.
Jacob Joshua Ross, “Where to Look for Miracles” (online) — summarized.
R. Ezra Bick’s VBM course on Ramban (Torat Har Etzion, online, free to read).
← Topic A4: What Ramban actually thought of Maimonides · Topic A6: The outcome: what stuck →
Back to the Nahmanides hub.