Topic A4 — What Ramban actually thought of Maimonides
Admiration with limits
The common picture of Ramban as simply “anti-Rambam” is wrong, and this topic exists to correct it. His position was admiration with limits, stated in his own words.
On the Mishneh Torah: it shows no leniency in interpreting prohibitions — it may even be more stringent — which in Ramban’s eyes was a positive. On the Guide: it was written not for those of unshaken belief, but for those led astray by Aristotle and Galen. Modern scholars note that this reading of the Guide’s purpose is not the consensus view; it is Ramban’s reading, and it is recorded as his.
He called Maimonides the pillar of Sepharad and defended his personal stature while rejecting his philosophical conclusions. The praise and the criticism belong together: the collection must carry his praise alongside his criticism, or it misrepresents him.
Open questions
None on the praise itself. The question is how to weigh it against the sharp language of his critiques — for example his words on Leviticus 1:9, in A5.
Sources and public-domain verdicts
The letter to the French rabbis (A2) — see the sources there.
His Torah commentary, where he engages Rambam constantly — Hebrew text public domain; Chavel’s English translation is CC-BY (verified on Sefaria, 2026-11-17 — see the licence note on the hub page). Strand A quotes nothing from Chavel.
← Topic A3: Ramban’s letter to Aragon, Navarre and Castile (about 1238) · Topic A5: The substantive disagreements: five fronts →
Back to the Nahmanides hub.