Ad Fontesto the sources

Topic A3 — Ramban’s letter to Aragon, Navarre and Castile (about 1238)

About 1238 · defending Solomon ben Abraham, refusing the bans. No author is named on this page.

Defending the man, refusing the party

Called on by Solomon ben Abraham — by then excommunicated by the Maimonists — Ramban wrote to the communities of Aragon, Navarre and Castile severely rebuking Solomon’s adversaries. He defended the man while still not joining his party.

The letter shows the two halves of his position at once: he defended the anti-Maimonist leader as a person and scholar, and he refused to endorse the bans. The first letter (A2) argued against the French ban; this one argues against the men who had banned the banner. Ramban would not let either side claim him.

Open questions

The dating (about 1238) is approximate, and the letter’s reception in the Spanish communities is thinly documented.

Sources and public-domain verdicts

The letter is in Kitvei Ramban — same sources as A2: Chavel’s edition (Mossad Harav Kook, 1963) is under copyright; reference only, nothing reproduced.

← Topic A2: Ramban’s letter to the rabbis of northern France · Topic A4: What Ramban actually thought of Maimonides →

Back to the Nahmanides hub.